WHAT CAUSED A MINNESOTA farmer to kill his entire family—his wife and four young children—with an ax in a horrific act of domestic violence?
We likely will never know the truth behind the murders-suicide which happened on March 24, 1917, in rural Redwood County, my home county in the fertile farmland of southwestern Minnesota.
Up until the release of a book of historical fiction, Sundown at Sunrise by former Minnesota state legislator Marty Seifert in late 2016, I’d never heard of this crime. I recently read the book published by Beaver’s Pond Press. Therein I found familiar names, including the maiden surname of my maternal grandmother and other known names from Redwood County.
Seifert grew up in Sundown Township within miles of the murders. In a farmhouse in Section 16 of Three Lakes Township north of Clements, William Kleeman, 31, raised an ax and killed his wife, Maud, and their children ranging in age from six weeks to five years. He then hung himself. Many times I’ve passed that former farm place at the intersection of Minnesota State Highway 68 and Redwood County Road 1 west of Morgan and near the site of Farm Fest. I had no idea of the violence that occurred there.
But the author grew up hearing the story of the Kleeman ax murders. That and his interest in history—he’s a former history teacher—prompted Seifert to research and pen this book rooted in fact.
I decided to check out for myself newspaper accounts of the murders. That led me to the Minnesota Digitized Newspaper Hub and sensationalized layered headlines followed by detailed stories. I expect Seifert used the same sources, and more, to research for his book. But he goes beyond those stories to suggest the real reason behind the crime discovered by a young teacher (her name is fictionalized in the book) who boarded with the Kleemans. I won’t share more. You need to read the book.
In reading Sundown at Sunrise, I noted specific red flags pointing to future domestic violence and an awareness of that potential. A hired hand, for example, tells Maud’s father upon her engagement to William Kleeman that, “I think Miss Petrie done deserve better.” Henry Petrie agrees.
The author also describes William Kleeman “from a young age parlaying his handsome looks and confident demeanor as ways to manipulate his mother.” That manipulative charm threads throughout the story. I appreciate that the author understands the characteristics of an abuser and writes that into this work of fiction based on fact.
And then, after the murders, the hired hand sees the Kleemans’ marriage certificate nailed above the bed where Maud and her baby lie in pools of blood. Frank Schottenbauer notes that “he’d rather look at a bloody corpse than view the license William Kleeman had used to violate Maud Petrie.”
The author many times works the appearance of garter snakes and William Kleeman’s aversion to religion into the storyline, alluding to evil.
You can surmise what you will from this book of historical fiction. But nothing changes the fact that Maud died at the hands of her husband and Gladys, Lois, Gordon and Rosadell died at the hands of their father in an unfathomable act of domestic violence in Redwood County, Minnesota.
Today I honor the memories of that young mother and her beloved children. They deserved to live full lives on the prairie, to love and to be loved.
FYI: The ax used in the murders is stored in the archives of the Redwood County Historical Society in Redwood Falls. For years, it was kept as evidence by the sheriff’s department before its donation to the county museum.
TODAY, AS YOUNG PEOPLE and others gather in Washington, DC, and around the world (including right here in Minnesota) for the “March For Our Lives” anti-gun-violence rally, I honor those I knew (via personal connections) who have been murdered in acts of domestic violence. Not just by gun violence, although several were shot.
Violence, whether in our schools, our homes, on the street, needs to stop. We need to take a stand, to act when we can, to say, “Enough is enough.” We need to care, to speak up, to listen, to educate ourselves, to push for change. I don’t pretend to have the answers. But I have witnessed and experienced the pain and grief of those who have lost loved ones through acts of violence. If you haven’t, consider yourself fortunate.
I’ve had to reach deep inside myself to comfort a friend whose father was murdered. I’ve had to reach deep inside myself to comfort parents whose daughter was murdered by her ex-boyfriend. I’ve had to reach deep inside myself to write about the murder of a beloved community member by her ex-husband at our local tourism office.
I’ve watched a SWAT team sweep through my neighborhood searching for a knife used in a murder within blocks of my home. I’ve talked to police many years ago about a drive by shooting involving big city gang members. A gang member purchased a car from us, failed to change the title, used the car in a shooting and then stashed the gun in the trunk. Investigators started with us, owners of the car.
Yes, I’ve been touched many times by violence. Gun and other.
Enough is enough. To those young people and others who are speaking up today, thank you for using your voice to effect change.
IMPORTANT: If you are in an abusive relationship and in immediate danger, call or text (if that option is available in your area) 911. If you are leaving (or thinking of leaving) your abuser, please seek help and have a safety plan in place. Talk to someone you trust like a family member, friend, c0-worker, clergy, advocate… Immediate help is available. Reach out to a local women’s shelter or advocacy center for professional help. You are not alone. You deserve to live a life free of any type of abuse whether physical, mental, emotional, psychological, financial, spiritual or technological.
Please know that you are in greatest danger when you are about to leave, are leaving or have left your abuser. Abuse is about power, control and manipulation. When abusers lose that control, they often become violent. Be safe and know that you are loved.
© Copyright 2018 Audrey Kletscher Helbling
Quoted passages are copyright of Marty Seifert and used here for review purposes only.
Thank you Audrey for reminding us of the importance of this horrible issue that just needs to stop. Hopefully someone who needs help will read this and be encouraged to GET OUT! This posting reminds me of a similar ax murder that happened in Rochester on February, 1988. A young boy kills his mom, dad and two young siblings with an ax. He was just 16 then and is presently serving 3 life sentences in the Stillwater facility. What in the world was going on in that home, how does a 16 year old become so violent to do what he did???? To this day, he won’t talk about it! ( His older brother was luckily not home that evening).
Why do I not remember this crime? But to read your words chills my bones. I feel for that older brother and for all who loved this family.
‘I think Miss Petrie done deserve better.”
Sometimes others SEE what we cannot.
WOW, this piece is heartbreaking & the signs were THERE from the beginning. The marriage cert above the bed. Omygoodness.
Thank you for your MOST powerful voice, Audrey.
xxx from Duluth.
—I hope we can meet this summer for coffee or wine.
Sometimes others SEE what we cannot see rings true. Love blinds us. Not only that, these abusers hold powerful manipulative skills.
Yes, on the meeting you.
Placed on my Facebook Page. Hope you don’t mind.
IRonic and Frightening.
Today is the DATE of that HORRIBLE crime.
Thank you for posting this on your Facebook page, Kim.
My thoughts are with you, my heart heavy, as you relive the realities of today. I’ll be in touch. Much love.
Wow. That is such an incredible story and I can imagine that the book is compelling. Thanks for the introduction to what would be a good book to read.
Yes, you need to read this book. And so do many others.
trajectory horrific crime.
In my job, I deal with the abused, the abuser and those who surround these folks, adults as well as children. The one thing I can say is that there is no way to tell what is happening within the privacy of the home and family life. Things often look “picture perfect” to outsiders. But many times the private lives of those who are abused is horrific.
I cannot imagine the stress of your job. But thank you for handling these abuse cases.
You are correct in that none of us knows what happens inside a home unless we are inside that home ourselves. Abusers excel at deception.
And victims hide the situation as part of their victimization. People often say “Why didn’t she get help?” Or “Why didn’t the kids say something?”, or my favorite “Why didn’t she leave?”. Fear is a strong inhibitor. Fear of harm to others (such as to your child, a younger sibling, or a parent ) can be even stronger.
Exactly. I heard that same question yesterday of “why?” Most people just don’t understand abuse, how the abuser manipulates and controls and instills fear. Thank God for the many advocates and others who help victims and survivors and are educating loved ones and communities on abuse.
I’m going to put in a plug here for She Stays, a book written by the executive director of HOPE Center in Faribault. Erica Staab writes in clear and understandable language about “why she stays.” It’s a must-read. Here’s a link: https://www.amazon.com/She-Stays-Erica-Staab/dp/1491267801
thanks for your continued diligence on social awareness of domestic abuse-a message that should stay continually on the forefront- never heard of this horrific crime and will look up book
You’re welcome. Given your interest in reading Minnesota authors, yes, you should read this book of historical fiction.
How awful to think of. This kind of abuse is nothing new it just reported more often. Heartbreaking
You’re right on this is nothing new, that it’s just reported more. And that’s good in creating awareness and affecting change.